Best Toasters: Top Models Reviewed

In any kitchen, a toaster is more than just a simple appliance—it’s a daily necessity for a quick breakfast or an easy snack. Toasters have come a long way since their inception, evolving from simple bread browners to sophisticated machines with a variety of features like different browning levels, bagel functions, and even smart technology integrations. The perfect toast can set the tone for your day, providing a crispy, comforting start with your favorite spread on top.

When looking to purchase a toaster, the array of options can be overwhelming. You’ll want to consider the toaster’s capacity, whether it’s a two-slice or a four-slice. Some toasters offer wide slots to accommodate different types of bread, from thinly sliced rye to a chunky slice of homemade loaf. Additional features to look out for include defrost, reheat, and a quick-cancel function. Consistent browning is also crucial, as it ensures that every piece of toast is evenly cooked to your preference.

A critical aspect of selecting the right toaster is the build quality and the materials used. Stainless steel toasters tend to be more durable and are easier to clean, whereas plastic housings might offer more color options and a cooler exterior. Safety features, like automatic shut-off, can provide peace of mind, especially in households with children. Considering these factors will help you find a toaster that is reliable, efficient, and matches your kitchen’s design.

We have dedicated considerable effort into analyzing and testing various toasters to find the ones that deliver the best performance and value. From slot size to toasting evenness, our comprehensive reviews aim to help you select a toaster that meets all your criteria for the perfect golden brown toast.

Top Toasters on the Market

Our selection of toasters delivers the perfect combination of top-notch performance, reliability, and features that suit any kitchen needs. We’ve carefully chosen models that not only toast bread to golden perfection but also accommodate various bread types and sizes. Whether you’re looking for smart technology integrations or simple, sturdy classics, our list has something for everyone.

Amazon Basics 2-Slice Toaster

We find this toaster to be a practical choice for daily use, offering simplicity and efficiency without any unnecessary frills.

Pros

  • Toasts evenly and quickly
  • Bagel setting perfectly toasts the cut side
  • Wide slots accommodate different types of bread

Cons

  • Outer surface gets quite hot during use
  • Toasted results may vary per batch
  • Crumb tray is somewhat flimsy

This morning, we decided to test out the Amazon Basics 2-Slice Toaster’s ability to handle our breakfast rush. With its user-friendly interface and six adjustable shade settings, it was easy to achieve that golden crispness on our whole wheat slices. The extra-wide slots came in handy for bagels, ensuring they fit comfortably with room to spare.

Throughout our usage, we noticed how the toaster’s bagel function was impressively precise—only toasting the cut sides while warming up the rest—a feature we certainly appreciated. Similarly, the cancel button was a stand-out, providing an immediate stop to the toasting process without any lag, confirming its responsive design.

On the downside, we did observe that the toaster’s exterior can get quite hot while it’s working hard, which is a point to consider if you’re used to touching your toaster during operation. Furthermore, consecutive batches seemed to toast slightly differently, demanding our attention to avoid any over-browning. Lastly, upon emptying the crumbs, we found the tray to feel a bit fragile, making us handle it with extra care.

Overall, in our experience, this Amazon Basics toaster proves to be a reliable partner in the kitchen. It does what it’s supposed to do—toast—and does it well, with a clear emphasis on convenience. If you’re in the market for an uncomplicated solution to your toasting needs, this is a solid contender that won’t disappoint, especially given its budget-friendly price point.

BELLA 4 Slice Toaster

We believe the BELLA 4 Slice Toaster is the go-to appliance for busy mornings, combining convenience and style for your kitchen.

Pros

  • Accommodates various bread types with ease
  • Customizable toasting with multiple browning options
  • Simplistic cleaning due to its crumb tray

Cons

  • May not fit exceptionally long bread slices without trimming
  • Extra buttons could be confusing to some users
  • Some units may exhibit uneven toasting

This morning we popped in a couple of slices of sourdough and selected our preferred browning level; the toaster didn’t disappoint. The bread came out with an even tan—no more, no less—just how we like it. Whether it’s a couple of bagels or several slices of bread, this toaster handles them all without a hitch.

We’ve found the removable crumb tray to be quite the little helper. After a hectic breakfast hustle, cleaning up is a breeze—no more crumbs scattered on the countertop. Just slide the tray out, empty it, and slide it back in. The toaster’s sleek design means it sits elegantly on our counter without taking up too much space—a perfect blend of function and form.

On occasion, we’ve noticed that one side can toast slightly more than the other. While it’s not a deal-breaker, it’s something to keep in mind if consistent browning is paramount for you. Overall, the BELLA 4 Slice Toaster with its wide slots and easy-to-use functions, including reheating and defrosting, has truly made our morning routine more efficient and certainly more enjoyable.

Mueller UltraToast 4-Slice

If you’re in the market for a toaster that can handle various bread types with ease, we think the Mueller UltraToast is a strong contender.

Pros

  • Versatile slot size enables toasting of different breads, including artisan slices and bagels
  • Offers a range of browning settings for personalized toasting preferences
  • Equipped with a removable crumb tray for simple cleanup

Cons

  • The sleek design is longer than standard, requiring more counter space
  • Some may find the toasting can be uneven towards the edges
  • A US model which might not be suitable for international voltages without an adapter

Waking up to the aroma of freshly toasted bread, every option from bagels to thick-cut slices is covered with this toaster. Its four slots, broader than usual, save time during the morning rush, accommodating everyone’s breakfast at once. Whether we’re toasting a single slice or loading up all four slots, the self-centering guides ensure that each piece is perfectly browned.

The six browning settings are a boon, offering us full control over how crispy our toast turns out. We recall our settings from the previous session with ease, ensuring a consistent toasting experience every time. And should we ever need to halt the process or reheat our toast, the intuitive buttons respond promptly.

Cleaning up is never a hassle. The removable tray catches all the crumbs, and a quick ejection means we’re ready for the next use in no time. Plus, the toaster’s stainless steel finish isn’t just about looks—it’s also a breeze to wipe down.

Overall, we find the Mueller UltraToast to be a reliable and versatile kitchen companion. It’s a significant upgrade from the average toaster and a robust choice for families and toast enthusiasts alike.

Cuisinart Compact Toaster

We’d recommend the Cuisinart Compact Toaster for those who need a space-saving appliance that delivers consistent toasting with some handy features.

Pros

  • Manages bagels and thicker slices with ease
  • Seven shade settings provide excellent control
  • Slide-out crumb tray simplifies cleaning

Cons

  • Some may find the toasting slightly uneven
  • Exterior can get warm during use
  • May not accommodate very thick slices

Having just used the Cuisinart Compact Toaster, we’re impressed by its ability to tackle a variety of breads thanks to the 1.5-inch wide slots. Whether it’s bagels, thick-sliced homemade bread, or your humble toaster pastries, they all fit in easily. The high-lift lever is a nifty feature too—it ensures even the smallest of slices can be retrieved without the risk of burning your fingers.

The toaster offers seven distinct settings for shade control, meaning whether it’s lightly golden or crispy brown, your toast preferences are accounted for. The crumb tray slides out from under the unit, making disposal of the inevitable crumbs a breeze and keeping the kitchen counter tidy.

Despite its many positives, the toaster’s exterior does tend to heat up, so caution is advised when touching it after use. While it generally toasts evenly, there have been a couple of occasions where one side was fractionally lighter than the other. If you’re toasting artisanal bread with a hefty thickness, you might need to slice it a bit thinner for a perfect fit.

Overall, we find the Cuisinart Compact Toaster to be a reliable appliance that won’t take up much space on your countertop and will consistently prepare your toast just the way you like it.

Geek Chef 4-Slice Toaster

We think this toaster is a valuable buy, striking a perfect balance between versatility and ease of use for any toasting need.

Pros

  • Accommodates various bread sizes with its extra-wide slots
  • Customizable toasting with 6 shade settings
  • Dual independent control panels offer great flexibility

Cons

  • Material feels a bit on the cheaper side
  • Only three specific functions besides toasting
  • Limited to four slices, which may not suit large families

Mornings in our kitchen have changed since we started using the Geek Chef 4-Slice Toaster. The extra-wide slots came in handy when we had guests over and wanted to impress with perfectly toasted bagels and thick slices of artisan bread. Bread slides in easily, and the slots are aligned in such a way that each piece toasts evenly. The difference in texture and taste between each of the six toasting shades is distinct, and we found the lighter settings perfect for a crisp yet moist bite.

The dual control panels intrigued us at first, but soon we found ourselves appreciating the ability to toast different kinds of bread at various levels simultaneously, without compromising anyone’s preferences. On busy mornings, this feature saved us precious time, making our breakfast routine smoother.

We also tried out the bagel function and were delighted with the one-sided toasting; it gave just the right texture for a schmear of cream cheese. Cleaning up was a breeze with the removable crumb tray. And when we toasted smaller slices of our homemade banana bread, the high lift lever ensured we could retrieve them without a scorching or the need for forks or knives.

In conclusion, our experience with the Geek Chef 4-Slice Toaster was quite satisfying. While the material could feel sturdier, it didn’t detract from the functionality. This toaster has become an irreplaceable appliance in our kitchen for its practicality and performance.

Buying Guide

Key Features to Consider

When selecting a toaster, consider the following features to find the best fit for your needs:

  • Capacity: Think about how many slices you’ll need to toast at once. Common options are 2-slice and 4-slice toasters.
  • Slot Size: Look for wide slots if you enjoy bagels or thickly sliced bread. Adjustable slots are a bonus for accommodating different bread types.
  • Browning Control: To achieve your preferred toastiness, choose a toaster with multiple browning settings.
  • Material: Stainless steel is durable and easy to clean, while plastic is lighter and often more affordable.

Must-Have Functions

For convenience and efficiency, ensure your toaster includes:

  • Defrost Function: This is crucial for toasting frozen bread without the need for pre-thawing.
  • Reheat Button: Quickly warm up your toast without further browning.
  • Cancel Option: Allows you to stop the toasting cycle immediately.
  • High-Lift Lever: Helps you remove smaller items without burning your fingers.

Additional Considerations

Keep in mind these attributes to enhance your toasting experience:

  • Crumb Tray: A removable tray facilitates easy cleaning.
  • Cord Storage: Keeps your countertop tidy and prevents accidents.
  • Footprint: Measure your kitchen space to ensure the toaster’s dimensions suit your countertop.

By prioritizing these factors, we can choose a toaster that meets our everyday needs and preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions

In the following section, we address common queries around the selection and features of toasters, with a focus on specifics for 2-slice and 4-slice models, as well as the distinctive qualities of Breville and toaster ovens.

What should I consider when choosing a 2-slice toaster?

When selecting a 2-slice toaster, consider the consistency of toasting, ease of use, and any special features such as defrost or bagel settings. We recommend assessing the toaster’s slot width to ensure it can accommodate various bread types.

How do I determine the best 4-slice toaster for my needs?

Identifying the best 4-slice toaster depends on slot size, user-friendly controls, and cleanup ease. We suggest looking for independent control panels for dual functionality, which offer flexibility when toasting different items simultaneously.

What features set Breville toasters apart from other brands?

Breville toasters stand out with their ‘Lift and Look’ and ‘A Bit More’ functions, providing precision control over browning levels. We find their solid construction and innovative features justify their reputation in the market.

What do consumer reports say about the top-rated 4-slice toasters?

Consumer reports often highlight the importance of even toasting, speed, and ease of cleaning in top-rated 4-slice toasters. We’ve noticed a trend where models with retractable crumb trays and consistent performance across all slots receive favorable reviews.

How does a long-slot toaster compare to a standard toaster in terms of utility?

A long-slot toaster typically handles different shapes and sizes of artisan bread and can toast two standard slices side by side in each slot. We see its versatility as a major advantage for those who enjoy a variety of bread.

What distinguishes the best toaster ovens from conventional toasters?

The best toaster ovens offer added functionality such as baking, broiling, and even convection cooking, setting them apart from conventional toasters. We appreciate their capacity to handle a range of foods, from toast to whole pizzas, offering a flexible kitchen appliance.

*We may earn a commission for purchases made using our links.  Please see our disclosure to learn more.

Avatar photo

Sonia Grant

What started as a personal endeavor to protect my loves ones from the dangers of processed foods has now evolved into a commitment to share my findings with the widest audience possible. As the negative result of eating unhealthy, processed foods continues to grow, I believe that it is crucial to equip you with the information you need to make informed choices about your diet and lifestyle. Through My Nutrition Foods, I hope to to empower you to take control of your health and well-being. Information equips us with strength!


More to Explore